MERRILL COPY CAT: Thundering Herd Is Stacking New Households Based on ‘Carrot and Stick’ Comp Plan

Whenever something of scale works at the wirehouses you can bet the others are going to do their best to copy it without making it look like they are copying it. Exhibit A is Merrill’s current comp plan adjustment based on new household additions, and whether or not an advisor makes the grade. 

Via Barron’s: 

“The wirehouse is on track to add 47,000 new households in 2019, Sieg said. That’s based on annualized first-quarter results and would mark a big increase over the 7,000 households Merrill added in 2017. Net new households added per advisor are now more than four, while the average Merrill Lynch household has about $1.4 million, he added.

“The wirehouse’s current compensation scheme includes a carrot-and-stick approach to getting the thundering herd to bring in new clients. An advisor’s pay suffers if he or she doesn’t bring in more than four new households and gets boosted if they recruit six or more.”

Those numbers have moved the needle enough to be highlighted on a BofA quarterly call. That in and of itself is meaningful. 

You can expect Morgan Stanley and UBS to devise likeminded scripts over the last half of 2019 and announce them internally early next year. Finding a meaningful ‘carrot and stick’ isn’t easy in today’s wealth management landscape. It seems Merrill did just that.

As the saying goes, “money talks and…” well, you know the rest. 

Share this article

Email
Twitter
LinkedIn
Author picture

Curious about switching broker dealers? Secure your 2 best offers all while remaining 100% anonymous.

Ready to start? Click here.

Leave a Reply

Secure Multiple Offers All While Remaining 100% Anonymous

CONTACT US

It’s one of the most important—and personal—questions a financial advisor can ask. Whether it’s frustrations with admin fees, limited platform flexibility, or just a gut feeling that you’ve outgrown your current firm, the decision to move shouldn’t be rushed. The right time to leave isn’t just about market timing—it’s about life timing.

If you’re weighing your options, we recommend this quick read: The Best Time for a Move—a blog and podcast episode that walks through key signals it may be time to explore a transition.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Going independent offers more control, higher payouts, and brand autonomy—but with added responsibilities. Wirehouses provide built-in infrastructure, brand recognition, and turnkey support—but often come with more restrictions and fees.

The real question is: Which model makes the most sense for your business goals and lifestyle?

To make a confident decision, you need to understand the economics behind both paths. Start by securing transition offers from top firms—independent and wirehouse—so you can compare side-by-side.

Get Your Offers in Hand

Our services are 100% free to financial advisors. We don’t charge you a dime. If you decide to make a move, the new firm pays us a finder’s fee—similar to a recruiter. But unlike recruiters, we’re not tied to any one firm, so we work to find your best fit, not theirs.

Want the full breakdown? Check out our blog post: How We Get Paid

© 2024 3xEquity, LLC. All rights reserved

Transition packages from top regional and national broker-dealers like LPL, Ameriprise, Wells Fargo, RBC, Cetera, Dynasty, UBS, and more.